NEW Protect your furbaby's laundry & wash their favorite items in style with our new Wash Bags! Learn More
Art-Logo article_img

Crate Training: To Crate or Not to Crate?

Crate training is the process where your dog accepts crate as a place to poop / pee. But many remain unsure on whether the best way to potty train their dogs is through crate training. Though some think that this ensures the dog is safe while at home, some also think otherwise.

"For your dog to feel secure, a crate can make him feel that way and he’ll feel at ease while at home, while you are away."

Here, we will set your mind at peace and help you weigh the pros & cons of crate training and assess if this is something that fits you and your fur-baby, with some alternatives you might want to consider to improve the quality of life of your dog.


Creates training process a lot easier

Potty training can be a stressful process for both you and your dog. If you have a crate that is big for your dog, this will prompt him to use one side as his toilet and will still give him enough space to lie down. He will learn to control his bladder and will go out of his crate when he needs to poop or pee. Not to mention, some dogs don't like to go potty in the same space they lay, which will train them to hold it in until otherwise; another potty/crate training method.

Calms down anxiety

Dogs are den animals and often find comfort in a den-like space such as a crate, under a table, or in any confining area. In order for a crate to offer your dog security, it must be “den like.” For your dog to feel secure, a crate can make him feel that way and he’ll feel at ease while at home, while you are away.

The crate you choose should be large enough for your dog to sit up, lie down and turn around comfortably. However, if your dog is also crate training, the dog should NOT have enough room to sleep in one corner and eliminate in another part of the crate.

Gives personal space

As den-dwelling animals, a crate will offer your dog a safe and quiet place for him to rest, to daydream (maybe), to chew on their favorite things, to hide from loud, scary noises


Makes your dog unhappy

Maybe at the beginning, when you start crate training your dog, that there will be a lot of barking, yelping and whining. Your dog does this with the hopes that you will open the crate for him. Situate the crate in an area in your house that is quiet, but be sure your dog can still see and hear you. Your dog is a social animal and for sure he wants to be with you and don't want to be isolated at all. Placing the crate in your bedroom at night will strengthen your bond with your dog by allowing him to sleep near you (while still inside his crate).

May be viewed as a punishment

For most dogs who’re still getting the hang of things, they can view pet training as a punishment. The longer you leave your dog inside the crate, the more he’ll think he has done something very bad to be put in that situation. If your dog spends a significant amount of time in a crate, it will also need a significant amount of time to exercise and play.

Can be dangerous!

Safety first. As pet parents, we are to make sure that the crate we use does not (in any way!) injure our pets. Remove any collar, harness or very small toys so there's no risk of snagging and choking.


The answer depends on you. You know your schedule, your lifestyle and you (of all people) should know what is best for your dog. Puppies demand a lot of attention and playtime and shouldn’t be staying long inside a crate. And even though many adult dogs can stay in their crates for long hours, it’s still best to always give them enough love, exercise and playtime!


If you are one of those people who can’t stand crate training for dogs because it’s cruel locking the dog inside, there are actually great alternatives. Depending on the given circumstances of your availability, lifestyle, etc, there are other ways, discussed below, you can contain your dog and prevent him from peeing/pooping in all the wrong places in your house and still give him the freedom he deserves.

Doggie Playpens

Doggie playpens are also called exercise pens. Available in many sizes, you can create a little area for your puppy within a room, without allowing access to your cabinets. They are larger than crates and provides your dog a more open area. You can create a little area for your dog within a room, without allowing access to your carpets and cabinets. This keeps them secure and safe in one spot without being as restricted and enclosed as most crates.

Fenced Yard

If you have a spacious lawn, you can secure a fence, and keep your dog outside. Just make sure he has a kennel /dog house to give him shade or protect him when it rains. But this might not be realistic enough if you don’t have the budget to build (which then leads us to…)

Dog Diapers / Belly Bands / Pee Pads

These are great options for you if you don't want to contain your dog. Dog diapers, belly bands and pee pads gives your dog the freedom to pee and poop and still keeps your house still clean.

Among everyone else, you know your dog better. Crate training is absolutely up to you and it's pros and cons will also depend on how you carry it out. Just remember to always offer your dog extra love, care and attention because things like this will take time.

"Dog diapers, belly bands and pee pads gives your dog the freedom to pee and poop and still keeps your house still clean."

The Author:

Micka V.

Micka Virtudazo is a full-time content creator at Pet Parents who lives with thirteen adorable American Bullies and a Shih Tzu-Maltese mix named Gretel. She especially enjoys writing how-to articles as she feels through this she can connect to other pet parents on a more personal level.

Read More